رسالة: T-S 13K2 + Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29
رسالة T-S 13K2 + Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29What's in the PGP
- صورة
- 1 Transcription
- 1 Translation
الوصف
Letter 2 of 4 of Letters Miscellany, a collection of letters representing both sides of the calendar controversy. Letter 2, of which only one folio is preserved, is a pro-Babylonian response to a Palestinian polemic on the calendar of 921/2 and on the Four Gates. The folio begins with the end of the end of the refutation of the Palestinians’ second argument. The Palestinians were arguing that the Four Gates are incomplete because they only account for four days of the week (the days on which the New Year is allowed to fall). Our letter responds that the Four Gates actually covers the full week because every period of time ends where the next one begins (fol.4r:1-5). The third argument concerns the rule of 641-642 parts. Our author misinterprets the rule as applying equally to Nisan and to Tishri, which enables him to refute it easily (fol.4r:5-14). Interjected here is a misplaced element of text that actually belongs to before the beginning of our folio. After the end of the misplaced text, the text resumes with the third argument (fol.4v:19-21).
العلامات
Editor: Stern, Sacha
Translator: Stern, Sacha (in English)
T-S 13K2 3r
T-S 13K2 3r + Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29r
- שפסק משם הוא מתחיל ומאי זה מקום פסק מחצי יום שלישי יפקחו
- עיניהם החברים ויראו התבונות העצומות האלה ואל יאמר כי ארבעה
- שערים אין בכלל אלא מעוט ימים ושעות שלד ימים בלבד כי האומר כן
- בלא דעת ובלא תבונה אמרה שאין העולם עומד אלא עליהם ואין תקנת
- המועדות תלויה אלא בהם והטעם השלישי שאמר בו אמרת
- ביומו במרת למחר אין לו עיקר מדברי חכמים ואף מי | שבדאו מתחילה
- וכתבו לא היה יודיע בסוד העיבור בין ימינו לשמאלו | כי אמר נולד ניסן
- באגה ותשרי בגהז עד שש שעות אין דוחין | אותו אחר שש שעות
- דוחין אתו ולא השיב אל לבו כי בהיולד | ניסן באגה קודם שש שעות
- יהיה כנגדו | תשרי בגהז לאחר שש שעות מפני שיש ביניהם שני ימים
T-S 13K2 3r + Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29r
-
… from where it stops, it starts. And from which place does it stop? From
Tuesday noon. Open
-
your eyes, colleagues, and see these tremendous contrivements. And let
him not say that the Four
-
Gates only include a minority of days and hours, only four (week)days—
because whoever says this,
-
says it without knowledge and understanding. For the world rests on these
(Gates) alone, and the correct dating of
-
the festivals depends only on them. And his third argument, in which he
said ‘641
-
on its day, 642 the next day’, has no root in the words of the Sages, and even
the one who originally contrived this (argument)
-
and wrote it did not know his right hand from his left regarding the secret
of the calendar, because he said that if Nisan is born
-
on Sunday, Tuesday, or Thursday and Tishri on Tuesday, Thursday, or
Sabbath until six hours, it is not postponed, (and if it is born) after six
hours,
-
it is postponed—and he did not notice that when Nisan is born on
Sunday, Tuesday, or Thursday before six hours,
-
the corresponding Tishri on Tuesday, Thursday or Sabbath will be after six
hours, because there are between them two (week)days,
Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29 29 recto
Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29r after join
- ארבע שעות תלח חלק . לפיכך בהולד ניסן בארבע שעות ביום יולד
- תשרי בשמונה שעות תלח חלק ואם דחינו ניסן מפני תשרי בטלו דבריו
- שאמ בניסן קודם חצות אן דוחין אותו . ואם לא דחינו תשרי מפני ניסן
- בטלו דבריו שאמ בתשרי לאחר חצות דוחין אותו . ואם יהי שעה
- שלימה יתר רנו חלקים וכן תקפט יהי שעה שלמה קנ חל כי כולם
- בתוספת אמרת והמשכילים יבינו . והשני שאמ בו שחשבון
- ד שערים אינו מחזיר אלא על ד ימים בלבד ומעוט שעות וחלקין
- הוכיח דברו עליו כאילו לא עבר על פתחה שלאומנות הזו כי חשבון ד
- שערים כולל את כל הימים ויש מהן ימים שהוא מזכירן שתי פעמים
- או שלושה אבל מי חכם ויבן אלה . והרי אני מפרש זאת בדרך קצרה
- [.................................................] עיבור ונולד קודם תצא משעה
-
four hours, [and] 438 parts, so that when Nisan is born at four hours of the
day, Tishri
-
will be born at eight hours 438 parts; and if we postpone Nisan because of
Tishri, this contradicts his rule
-
that Nisan before noon is not postponed; and if we do not postpone Tishri
because of Nisan,
-
this contradicts his rule that Tishri after noon is postponed. And if {will [nb: scribe begins misplaced text here] be a full
-
hour plus 256 parts, and so 589 will be a full hour [and] 150 parts, and so all
of them
-
by adding 641. And the intelligent will understand (Dan. 12:10). As to the
second [argument], in which he said that the calculation
-
of the 4 Gates only covers 4 [week]days alone and a minority of hours and
parts,
-
his discourse demonstrates that he has not gone past, as it were, the
entrance of this art. For the calculation of the 4
-
Gates includes all the [week]days, and among them some [week]days are
mentioned two or three
-
times—but whoever is wise, let him understand these (Hosea 14:10). And
behold, I shall explain this briefly.
-
["If any Tishri in whose year there is an inter]calation is born before 491
[parts] of the
T-S 13K2 3v
T-S 13K2 3v + Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29v
-
ninth hour of Friday day, [the months are] defective. And if it is born after
that, they are full." For when you
-
add 5 days, 21 hours, [and] 589 parts, [the molad] will reach the end of
the 6th [hour] of Thursday day. Behold, you have learnt
-
that it mentions Thursday day, and it says: "if it exceeds six hours, it is
postponed." And furthermore,
-
it is said: "and if there is no intercalation in this or in the following year,
and it is born before 408 parts of the 1st
-
5 hour of Friday night, they are defective; and if it is born afterwards, they
are full." For when you add
-
twice 4 days, 8 hours, (and) 876 parts for two years, it will reach the end of
-
six hours on Saturday day. Behold, you have learnt that it mentions the day
of Sabbath, and it says: "after
-
six hours, it is postponed." And furthermore, it is said: "and if there is an
intercalation in the following year, and it is born
-
before 204 parts of the 10th hour of Friday night, they are defective. And if
it is born after that,
-
they are full." For when you add 4 days, 8 hours, [and] 876 parts,
-
it will reach the end of six hours on Tuesday day. Behold, you have learnt
that it mentions Tuesday day,
-
and it says: "after six hours, it is postponed." And you have already men-
tioned Monday—
-
we have explained this in the first argument—so it is plain that it has
mentioned all the [week]days. And the other
-
Gates repeat the [week]days: for the limit of 491 [parts] which is on Sunday
nights
-
repeats the mention of [the limit of] six hours on Sabbath day; and the
limit of 204 which is on Sunday
-
nights repeats the mention of six hours on Thursday; and the limit of 589
which is on Monday
-
repeats the mention of six hours of six hours on Tuesday of the previous
year. And similarly, the limit of
-
204 which is on Tuesday nights and the limit of 695 which is on Wednes-
day nights repeat a third time the mention
Bodl. MS Heb. d 74/29 29 verso
T-S 13K2 1r
T-S 13K2 1v
T-S 13K2 2r
T-S 13K2 2v
T-S 13K2 4r
T-S 13K2 4v
T-S 13K2 5r
T-S 13K2 5v
T-S 13K2 6r
T-S 13K2 6v